top of page

What Makes College Admissions Essay Writing "Authentic?"

Writer: Nathan Hurwitz
Nathan Hurwitz
Nov 9
2 min read

Every consultant says they want college admissions to include “authentic” essay writing. Here’s what I actually mean by that word, because it usually gets used as marketing rather than a real standard.

Specific, not casual

Authentic doesn’t mean casual or unpolished. It means specific — a detail only this particular student would notice, a way of thinking that’s actually theirs. As someone who spent years directing actors and listening for a performance that rang false, I can hear the difference between a kid’s real voice and a voice that’s been smoothed out by too many editors.

Protecting the voice, not erasing it

My job is protecting that real voice, not sanding it down. That standard changes how I edit: I’m listening for the sentence that sounds like nobody else, not the sentence that reads the most impressively on paper.

Dr. Hurwitz seeks to make every sentence sound like only your student could have written it - avoid general statements that could have been written by anyone.
Dr. Hurwitz seeks to make every sentence sound like only your student could have written it - avoid general statements that could have been written by anyone.

Do's & Don'ts

DO

DON'T

✓  Look for one detail in an essay only that student would notice.

✗  Don’t confuse “authentic” with “unpolished” or “casual.”

✓  Preserve a student’s natural sentence rhythm during edits.

✗  Don’t let heavy editing smooth a student’s real voice into a generic one.

✓  Ask whether a revision sharpens the voice or just polishes it away.

✗  Don’t reward vocabulary that sounds more like an adult than a teenager.

✓  Choose an editor who protects voice, not one who standardizes it.

✗  Don’t treat every editing pass as automatically an improvement.

 

DR. HURWITZ'S TAKE

My job is protecting that real voice, not sanding it down. If you want an editor who protects your kid’s voice instead of erasing it, that’s the whole standard I hold every draft to.

 

Ready for a clear, honest read on where your student stands?

If you want an editor who protects your kid’s voice instead of erasing it, grab the free Essay Brief, or book a $250 / 55-minute session with Dr. Nathan Hurwitz — no long-term package required.

hurwitzadmissions.com  |  nathan@hurwitzadmissions.com  |  (203) 613-9262


 

Dr. Hurwitz talks about what makes a college application essay feel "authentic."

Comments


bottom of page