The Cornell Case: What Works to Stop Campus Sexual Assault? What the Evidence Shows
Bystander programs have the best-studied results, with real caveats.
The strongest evidence so far is for bystander programs that train a campus or school community to notice and interrupt risky situations. In a cluster-randomized trial of the Green Dot program across 26 Kentucky high schools (about 89,707 student surveys), the rate of sexual-violence perpetration in intervention schools was 0.83 times that of controls in year 3 and 0.79 times in year 4, with similar patterns for victimization, harassment, stalking, and dating violence. The authors estimate 120 violent events were prevented in year 3 and 88 in year 4.

Estimated reductions in violence where Green Dot ran: 17% and 21% in a randomized high-school trial, 25% and 21% in an observational college study, no significant change in unwanted-sex perpetration.
A college comparison (Coker et al., 2015) followed 7,111 first-year students at three public universities. At the Green Dot campus, unwanted-sex victimization was about 25% lower (adjusted rate ratio 0.75) and overall interpersonal-violence perpetration about 21% lower (0.79). But there was no significant difference in unwanted-sex perpetration, the study was observational rather than randomized, and the gap faded in 2013 as intensive training declined. The authors call it a promising strategy that needs more rigorous research.
Other evidence points the same way. A 2007 Education Department-funded study found that freshman men who completed a rape-prevention program before joining a fraternity were significantly less likely to commit sexually coercive acts. The Cornell Daily Sun reported that a men’s program for fraternity members is under development, though no results exist yet, and Cornell’s Oct. 13 plan to fund “safe social alternatives” to house parties is untested. Alcohol is a recurring factor in the data. New York’s amnesty rule removes a barrier to bystanders calling for help. The practical takeaway is that sustained, repeated programming with training for peer leaders appears to matter more than a one-time orientation session; ask any college how it is evaluated.
Key facts
• Green Dot, 26 Kentucky high schools — Randomized trial. Perpetration rate ratio 0.83 (year 3), 0.79 (year 4); about 120 and 88 events prevented
• Green Dot, 3 public universities — Observational, n=7,111. Unwanted-sex victimization aRR 0.75; no significant change in unwanted-sex perpetration
• Prevention before joining — Funded study: freshman men with prevention training before joining a fraternity were less likely to commit coercive acts
• Caveat — Effects faded when intensive training declined; more rigorous college research needed
What they’re saying
• Federal researchers · Authors of the CDC-archived Green Dot trial: Estimated about 120 and 88 violent events prevented in years 3 and 4 at 26 Kentucky high schools. (CDC Stacks)
• Researchers · Coker et al., college Green Dot study: Called the program promising but urged more rigorous research. (PubMed Central)
• Greek-life industry · Dawn Wiese, fraternity insurance officer: Argued for education and prevention rather than bans, citing research on fraternity members intervening. (NYT via Philadelphia Inquirer)
• Women’s and legal advocates · Diane Rosenfeld, Harvard Law School Gender Violence Program: Said college presidents could make a “huge difference” by hosting office hours or town halls. (Boston Globe, Sept. 30)
Dr. Hurwitz’s Take
The honest framing for parents: prevention is not magic and no single program is proven everywhere. But the best-supported approach is also the most practical one: train a critical mass of students to step in, keep training them, and measure outcomes. When a college tells you it has “a program,” ask how many students, how often, led by whom, and what the evaluation found.
Action checklist
• ✓ Ask: is bystander training ongoing across all four years, or a one-time orientation video?
• ✓ Ask who is trained (athletes, Greek leaders, RAs) and how effectiveness is measured.
• ✓ Ask what programming exists specifically for men and for chapter leaders.
• ✓ Ask about alcohol policy and how amnesty is explained to students.
Key sources





Comments